If we look just at how each party did in its margins of victory each year, you can see 1) that most races are won by 10 points or more, and 2) Republicans had a remarkably low number of victories that were in the single digits -- 17 to be exact. That's the lowest number of similarly close races for either party in any of the last four cycles.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/aa9ad/aa9ad7a1d63ca55044ca73273df66b0350c3671d" alt=""